A wide open barrel at golden hour with a jungle treeline behind
BommieSurf vs Surfline · the honest read

Looking for a Surfline alternative?

Surfline is very good at what it's built for. This page is about what it isn't built for — the breaks you pin yourself, scored the way you surf them.

Updated

The short answer

Get it on Google Play Download on the App Store

What Surfline does better

Live cams at hundreds of breaks. If you want to see the water before you drive, that is what they are for.

A global database of named spots, with guides built from local input.

Forecasters who physically observe conditions at hundreds of spots and override the model when it's wrong. Their top two ratings can only be given by a human who has actually seen it, which is the right call and an expensive one.

Thirty-five years of observations behind their model, and an ecosystem around it — cam rewind, session clips, reports.

All of that is real — cams, coverage, forecasters. What none of it produces is a rating that belongs to you rather than to the spot.

The view from inside a barrel, looking out at a jungle island

Where BommieSurf is different

The same wave is a different wave depending on who is paddling out. One surfer wants it head-high and pushing. Another wants it smaller and cleaner on a longer board. A third only rates it on a dropping tide with some north in the wind. A single rating has to pick one of them and be wrong for the other two.

BommieSurf doesn't rate the break. It rates the break against the conditions you set for it — your swell range, your wind directions and tolerance, your tide window, the way you like to surf that particular spot. Three people can save the same break and get three different scores for the same hour, and all three are right.

Surfline's own support documentation is clear about this. At most spots, the model rating is worked out from surf height and wind. Ratings that don't come from a forecaster, they say, can miss things like a very high tide slowing down a tide-dependent spot. Their advice to users is that there's no substitute for local knowledge, and to always factor in what you know about the tides and banks at your break.

We agree with every word of that. BommieSurf is where that knowledge goes.

You set the tide window for a break once — the sweet spot between low and high, whether it wants the tide rising or falling, and whether the break simply doesn't work outside that window — and every daylight hour gets scored against it, at twenty per cent of the total. Each break can draw from its own tide station. You only have to know your break once. The full method, with worked examples, is on the scoring page.

There is no public spot list in BommieSurf. You drop a pin and set what that break wants. Nothing you save appears in a shared map or a directory, because there isn't one to appear in. That's a real limit on how big this can get, and it's the point.

Some apps score your sessions by learning from the ones you log, and need a season of them before they're much use. BommieSurf asks you what the break wants up front, because you already know. It scores correctly from the first forecast.

Every new account gets seven days of Pro without a card. It never turns into a paid subscription — when the week is up the account drops to Free, and there's nothing to cancel because there was never anything to cancel.

Side by side

BommieSurfSurfline
Spot coverageBreaks you pin, anywhere on any coastGlobal database of named spots
Live camsNoneHundreds of breaks
Who sets the conditionsYou, for each breakSpot-wide, from the model or a forecaster
Tide in the ratingScored, twenty per cent, against your windowIncluded where a forecaster observes the spot; at most spots the model uses height and wind
DetailEvery daylight hour, scored out of tenHourly rating, five bars, seven labels
RangeNine days, the marine model's real horizonSixteen days
Getting startedSet each break's conditions onceNothing to set

What happened to Magicseaweed

Surfline bought Magicseaweed in 2017 and retired it in 2023. The address now takes you to Surfline, and a lot of people have still not forgiven it.

BommieSurf is not a replacement for what Magicseaweed was. There's no free public lookup for a named break here and there never will be. If what you miss is a straight read on a break you already know, that's a different thing, and it might be this.

Which one you want

Use BommieSurf

Your breaks aren't on a public list, or the public read doesn't match what you see. You know your tide window. You want an hour, not a day rating.

Use Surfline

Your break has a cam. You travel and need a spot database. You want a forecaster who has looked at it this morning.

Use both

The common answer. Surfline for the cams and the trip planning, BommieSurf for the call at the breaks you actually surf.

Questions

Is this page biased toward BommieSurf?

Obviously. We wrote it. What we've tried to do is keep every factual claim about Surfline sourced to Surfline — the tide section links straight to their support documentation so you can read it yourself, and the list of what they do better is there because it's true, not for balance.

Does BommieSurf have surf cams?

No, and it isn't going to. Cams are a network, not a feature.

Can I use both?

Yes, and plenty do. They answer different questions.

Is BommieSurf cheaper than Surfline?

We don't publish price figures here. The App Store and Google Play are the source of truth, and the two stores don't line up exactly, so any number on this page would be wrong for somebody.

Does it work outside Australia?

Yes — the forecast data is global. There's more on coverage in our FAQ.

Know your next session

Pin your breaks, set what they want, and get every daylight hour scored for nine days.

Get it on Google Play Download on the App Store